President Donald Trump and his administration have relished complete control of Washington for the past 23 months, taking every opportunity to go after Democrats and Trump’s perceived enemies, paying no mind to the lawfulness of their actions. Now, as Democrats prepare to take over control of Congress with comfortable majorities, they’re bringing the same zeal in announcing their intent to investigate Trump’s Cabinet, donors, and allies for corruption and possible violations of federal law. Republicans are in pure panic mode over this. Some members of the administration have even been engaging in a desperate intimidation act, sending letters to top Democrats warning that these lawful efforts may be “infringing on First Amendment rights.” Attorney General Todd Blanche went so far as to state that he would use his Justice Department to initiate counter-investigations into Democrats who conduct oversight into the Trump administration. It seems as though the president and his allies already can’t handle the heat. It makes sense, given that there should be a lot of heat coming their way.
On election night, California Rep. Rob Garcia was the first to fire shots, just as the depth of Democrats’ sweep of the nation was beginning to set in. “LAWYER UP,” the incoming House Oversight Committee chair posted on X. Others quickly followed suit. “First Hegseth … Then Homan. Belt to ass. HOLD THEM ALL ACCOUNTABLE,” North Carolina Rep.-elect Richard Ojeda also said on X. New Jersey Rep. Analilia Mejia announced that Democrats would soon begin handing out subpoenas “like Mardi Gras beads,” while Rep.-elect Emily Randall likened it to candy. Sen. Ed Markey took it a step further, saying, “They are going to need to plant new forests for all of the subpoenas we’ll be printing.”
This Democratic grandstanding came at a moment when liberals across the country were rejoicing at a blue tsunami not seen in some 30 years. And, sure, these comments are provocative, but they are grounded in real oversight powers that Democrats have now earned and are linked to serious concerns about the administration’s corrupt dealings, plus the Iran war and the ongoing affordability crisis. “Next year, Democrats must pass bills powerful enough to actually tackle the cost of living crisis and root out rampant corruption. We cannot be the party of nervous lawyers who just tinker around the edges,” Congressional Progressive Caucus Chair Greg Casar said on X days before the midterm elections. Now that we know the full contours of the party’s congressional victories—on Tuesday night, Alaska became the last Senate race called, with Democrat Mary Peltola’s win securing a 56-seat Democratic majority in the upper chamber—many members are simply indicating they are ready to roll up their sleeves and get to work.
Cue the Republican freak-out. Days after the midterm elections, Trump took to Truth Social to call Democrats “extortionists” who were engaging in “weaponization and lawfare” for suggesting any oversight of his administration. He ended his rant with a direct call to action for the DOJ to “look into” these “criminal” acts. It’s important to say, flatly, that nothing Democrats have said is remotely criminal, nor should it be misconstrued as an intention to commit unlawful harm to anyone. The Constitution’s speech or debate clause protects members of Congress and their aides from criminal prosecution or civil suits when their actions are taken within the legislative sphere, because holding oversight hearings and issuing subpoenas are among legislators’ core responsibilities.
This fact does not seem to matter to the president’s loyalists, since their principal concern seems to be proving their fealty to the king. This is particularly true of Aaron Reitz, the 39-year-old U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, who took it upon himself to send letters to at least three Democratic lawmakers accusing them of engaging in unlawful activity after they pledged to investigate the Trump administration. After Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, who is set to become chair of the Senate Banking Committee, said in a Time magazine op-ed that she wants to bring in Big Tech CEOs, Wall Street executives, and corporations for questions about possible unlawful activity, Reitz decided to send her a letter. Accusing Warren of being on “the warpath to wield her committee gavel like a tomahawk, seeking the scalps of those who associate ‘too closely’ with President Trump,” Reitz ordered her to save all documentation related to any congressional investigations she conducts or risk violating federal law. This is not only racially charged (Warren has been a punching bag of the right for years for having overstated her Native American heritage) but legally absurd.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal, who is set to chair the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, meanwhile, received a similar letter from Reitz after demanding answers from previously undisclosed donors who collectively handed over $330 million to fund Trump’s ballroom construction. Reitz accused Blumenthal of threatening U.S. citizens for associating themselves with Trump and ordered him to preserve all documentation relevant to his investigation. Blumenthal, a former U.S. attorney himself, responded in kind, stipulating that Reitz preserve any information regarding his threatening letters and doubled down on his intention to investigate Trump donors. This is the appropriate response: Reitz is a subsidiary officer and can come under investigation and ultimately impeachment by Congress if he violates the powers of his office, as certainly appears to be the case with these letters.
“The public deserves to know the terms under which dozens of American companies were persuaded to donate millions of dollars to the President’s vanity projects,” Blumenthal wrote, “and whether lawsuits were dismissed, contracts were awarded, or regulations went unenforced in exchange for that money.” He ended his letter to Reitz with the same demands to preserve all documentation related to Reitz’s decision to draft and publicly post his letter to Blumenthal.
Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin was also a recipient of a Reitz letter for telling Vox reporters, in a podcast interview, that Democrats should pursue investigations into alleged government misconduct. “We do have to have accountability for the unbelievable corruption that we are living under right now,” she said, adding, “You have to pick signature cases, and you have to go after people and projects that are super egregious.” Slotkin suggested that the people around Trump who are “doing his bidding and enabling” him also be investigated. Reitz took issue with this, writing to Slotkin that any investigations Democrats pursue must have a legitimate legislative purpose and can’t be for “personal aggrandizement of the investigators or to ‘punish’ ” Trump officials.
Reitz’s actions here are particularly rich, given that the president has spent years publicly disparaging Democrats and others whom he dislikes, baselessly accusing them of crimes and ordering his DOJ to investigate—consider Letitia James, James Comey, Adam Schiff, David Hearn, Cassidy Hutchinson, and many more. After investigations were started, the cases largely fell apart after judges dismissed them for lack of legal basis or federal prosecutors recognized their weaknesses and simply dropped them. Meanwhile, what Slotkin, Blumenthal, and Warren have planned is not lawfare; it reflects legitimate concerns about the president’s abuse of power that lawyers, former federal employees, and the American public have been waving red flags about ever since Trump began his second term.
The Campaign for Accountability, a nonpartisan watchdog group, called foul on Reitz and submitted a formal complaint against him with the State Bar of Texas for potentially violating the group’s professional conduct rules. “The Constitution places senators’ investigative acts beyond the reach of prosecution, and nothing in the public records supports the charges Mr. Reitz invoked,” the complaint states, while suggesting that this could be a violation of a Texas bar rule that bans prosecutors from “threatening to prosecute a charge that the prosecutor knows is not supported by probable cause” and makes it a crime to obstruct congressional inquiry “by any threatening letter or communication.”
It’s bizarre that Reitz is involving himself at all, given that he’s a U.S. attorney for Texas, nowhere near the Democrats he has threatened. “U.S. attorneys don’t just freelance anywhere without being assigned,” Harry Litman, a former U.S. attorney and deputy assistant attorney general, noted. Joyce Vance, a former U.S. attorney for Alabama, made a similar observation in her Substack: “If the Attorney General had designated him to investigate, that would be an official matter, and it would be public,” she wrote, “like when Attorney General Bill Barr designated Connecticut U.S. Attorney John Durham with investigating the origins of the Russia probe following the 2016 election. That hasn’t happened, at least not yet.”
As of last week, Blanche was clearly distancing himself from Reitz when asked about him. “I’m the attorney general, so I don’t oversee every single thing that’s done.”
Meanwhile, Democrats are clearly unimpressed with Reitz, Blanche, and the rest of the administration’s hollow threats. On Wednesday, Garcia proceeded to send a dozen notices to the president’s family, Vice President J.D. Vance, and current and former administration officials informing them of impending investigations and to preserve any relevant documents they have.
“We won’t be intimidated as we seek truth and justice,” Garcia said Wednesday on Bluesky. “Our investigations have a clear purpose: expose corruption, and pass strong legislation to ensure it never happens again.”
We hope you learned a thing or two from this edition of Executive Dysfunction. If you enjoyed reading it, please consider supporting our legal journalism by becoming a Slate Plus member!
Elsewhere in Jurisprudence
On this week’s Amicus, Slate executive editor Susan Mathews takes over the host chair and discusses how the Supreme Court will likely seek to rehab its image in a post–blue wave world. Joined by Alex Aronson from Court Accountability, they remind us why a few reasonable opinions shouldn’t fool anyone into thinking the justices have suddenly changed their tune.
On the Amicus bonus episode, Balls and Strikes takes over, with Madiba K. Dennie and Jay Willis unpacking the latest case consuming the court. Nielsen v. Watanabe considers whether federal agents should be given even more impunity than they already have.
K. Sabeel Rahman, professor of law at Cornell Law School, argues that for democracy to actually survive in this moment, lawmakers must do more than change policy: They need to remake the bureaucracies and institutional structures that have enabled autocratic overreach, and that means restructuring federal agencies and addressing for-profit corporations and oligarchs head-on.
With their historic blue tsunami and near-insurmountable majorities in both houses of Congress, Democrats have a critical opportunity to take back reproductive rights. Rachel Rebouche and Mary Ziegler argue that Democrats cannot wait until a conservative victory in federal court to do something, especially as the Trump administration and red states have already moved to limit medication abortion.
Thank you for reading Executive Dysfunction! We’re thrilled to be in your feeds and will be back with more dysfunction analysis next week.

![Enjoy the [Road] Show Travel Mug with Handle, 14ozEnjoy the [Road] Show Travel Mug with Handle, 14oz](https://georgemagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/479070202831754764_2048-300x300.jpeg)


Discount Applied Successfully!
Your savings have been added to the cart.